The Greatest Film I’ve Never Seen Blogathon: Pickpocket (1959)

greatest1Debbie at Moon in Gemini is hosting The Greatest Film I’ve Never Seen Blogathon, which is a fabulous idea since it is an opportunity for everyone to discover or re-discover classic and “must-see” films, or even find hidden gems. I have chosen to write on Robert Bresson’s “Pickpocket” because it is considered one of the greatest of films (at least in some circles). It is a definite achievement of Robert Bresson, an acclaimed film director, and the film is ranked as one of the greatest films by the Sight & Sound magazine (the 2012 poll). Moreover, Roger Ebert, the late popular film critic, once included it in his “Great Movies” list. And, “Pickpocketis great, just not in a conventional way. This is because Bresson is a French director who practices some form of austerity in his films, and his films do have a minimalistic quality, even though all the philosophical observations in his movies more than make up for the understated presentation or plot. 

Pickpocket Poster Pickpocket (1959)

This film is Bresson’s debut as a scriptwriter for his movie, but it is also fair to say that he was in some way adapting Dostoevsky’s novel “Crime and Punishment” (1866) to make this film because “Pickpocket” more or less follows the stages of Dostoevsky’s novel and has similar characters. Like in the classic novel, Bresson is preoccupied with fear, guilt and redemption in his story as we follow Michel (Martin LaSalle), a recently released thief, who struggles to get back to his “job”. Michel is reclusive and apathetic, but he does make friends with Jeanne (Marika Green), a young woman and his mother’s neighbour, and has a friend called Jacques. Bresson conveys to the screen the intrigue of the trade which is called pick-pocketing, as well as its dangerous, claustrophobic and lonely nature. What works best in the film is the portrayal of Michel as a societal outsider who tries inwardly to come to light and good. The main character becomes quite sympathetic, maybe even more sympathetic than in “Crime Punishment”, because the crimes of Michel are less horrendous than the murders of Raskolnikov. 

Bresson once recommended to build one’s film “on white, on silence and on stillness”, and some of this advice is evident in “Pickpocket”. The film, which is minimalistic in its presentation, almost solely concentrates on the main character, while it builds its gloomy Kafkaesque atmosphere as a setting. The inexplicable awkwardness of the characters as they converse with one another and the oppressing surroundings probably reflect the heaviness of Michel’s conscience, as he goes on his daily pick-pocketing activities. When the film does not concentrate on Michel’s dilemmas, it presents a quite insightful world of small thieves operating in a large city. We get to know their practices and trainings, for example, the fact that they must exercise their fingers constantly for them to remain flexible for the job, and we do get to know the thieving techniques used, such as the diversion of a victim’s attention. Apparently, the art of pick-pocketing was so realistically presented in the movie that the film was banned in Finland until 1965, if IMDb is to be believed. And, the practices of thieves are quite intriguing to watch, because Bresson zooms his camera on the actions of the quick hands of thieves, and also on bags and wallets.

Pickpocket” is not heavy on action and may appear slow-moving. However, for the lovers of psychological character studies, there is a lot here to discover. Part of the appeal of the film is that Michel is so enigmatic as a personality. He is going through some kind of an existential crisis and may have a depression. He feels alone in a city where he cannot have a legitimate job and has few friends. His responses in conversations are puzzling, and that mysterious aspect to his personality is also what keeps our interest in the story. For example, in one scene, where Michel successfully steals money, he muses to himself why he even needs them and is unsure what they will bring, and, in another scene, he quite categorically refuses to admit he needs a job. This contradictory information and Michel’s apathy may be off-putting for the viewers, but Bresson also knows that, only in this way, he can get at the core of his character’s uncertainty, presenting the character’s fear of the future. Michel has to appear both ordinary and extraordinary (or odd (a society’s stranger)) at the same time.

Michel’s relationship with his mother in the film is yet another aspect which confuses and unsettles. In writing the script, Bresson probably had regard to Camus’s “The Stranger” (1942), where the main character also shows outward indifference to his mother, even though, deep inside, he may love her as much as any other son would. Similarly, Michel inquires about his mother in the movie, who is on her death-bed, but he does not visit her at first. This behaviour puzzles Jeanne (Marika Green), who plays a role of ingénue in this story, because she does not take Michel for a heartless person. Even Michel’s relationship with members of the opposite sex in the movie is reminiscent of the existential work of Kafka, most notably in “The Trial” (1925). Michel remains polite and detached with Jeanne, while he repeatedly questions after the Last Judgement and even tries to justify his actions by recourse to Robin Hood-type scenarios. Paul Schrader is probably the man who simulated Bresson’s ideas more often in his films, and the inward existential anxiety of the male characters and the austere presentation are evident in Schrader’s script to “Taxi Driver” (1973) and in Schrader’s film “First Reformed (2018), respectively.

PickpocketMartin LaSalle is a very interesting choice for the lead role of Michel. It is the actor’s debut and his self-consciousness sometimes shows, but that “fault” actually suits the film and its goals well. Michel should be a bit imperfect, shy and self-conscious how he presents himself to the world (he is an imperfect thief), and LaSalle delivers just that. Thieves should be “invisible” human beings, but the lead actor is handsome and memorable. He has these facial features which remind of Daniel Day-Lewis, who with his understated presentation and silent demeanour could nevertheless project the aura of utter conviction and belief. In the film, LaSalle has something of this quality too, and, with his silent stares and a quiet demeanour, the actor convinces the audience of his character’s internal struggle. Something similar could be said about Marika Green in the role of Jeanne. This is the actress’s debut, and she, as well as LaSalle, does not have to go far to find her character, since she and LaSalle play essentially themselves. Green was only 16 in the film, and Jeanne should be a bit self-conscious, shy and naïve young woman. Bresson once said that films “can only be made by by-passing the will of those who appear in them, using not what they do, but what they are.” In some way, it can be argued that LaSalle and Green definitely portray what they are (if only in some small dosage), for example, both are new to film-making, and, thus, unsure of everything.

Pickpocket” is a French-language film with an unusual quality to it because it prioritises its character study, trying to delve into one solitary and misunderstood human condition. In that way, the film makes the biggest impact in its existentialist message, even though the director’s unhurried way to present scenes is also interesting. The only downside is that the film could have had more punch in the end regarding Michel’s remorse, which remains somewhat unconvincing. 9/10

Advertisements

19 Responses to The Greatest Film I’ve Never Seen Blogathon: Pickpocket (1959)

  1. Pingback: The Greatest Film I’ve Never Seen Blogathon is Here! – MOON IN GEMINI

  2. I’ll admit to not having the best relationship with French dramatic films, but I will make a note to consider this fascinating sounding movie to my “get to it” list.

  3. Chris says:

    I’ve seen bits and pieces of Pickpocket and should give the film a proper watch. I vaguely remember the pick pocketing is well edited, but as you say there is much more to it. Thanks for the heads-up!

  4. There are so many terrific films. Most never are mentioned in “greatest” lists.

    Anyway, among those that usually are listed on “greatest” lists, I’ve yet to see Grand Illusion and Bridge Over The River Kwai, and numerous others.

    See you —
    Neil S.

  5. Bresson is an extraordinary director. In my opinion, his best work is “Diary of a Country Priest.” It captures the existential dilemmas, trials and tribulations of a priest masterly. I haven’t seen Pickpocket, but I plan to in the near future. Interesting review, you motivated me to see it. Tarkovsky listed Bresson’s “Mouchette” as one of his top 10 films.

    • dbmoviesblog says:

      I agree that he is impressive. I have heard that if one has seen Schrader’s First Reformed, one also kind of “seen” Diary of a Country Priest 🙂 I have reviewed First Reformed, but am yet to see Diary of a Country Priest, thanks for the recommendation!

  6. voiceovermovies says:

    I’ve seen three of Bresson’s films and this I felt the most distant from, although it was still interesting. Well done review.

    • dbmoviesblog says:

      Thanks! I guess I was simply the perfect viewer for “Pickpocket”. Being a fan of existentialist authors, I liked how the film incorporated the literary ideas, and I enjoyed uncovering the world of pickpocketing.

  7. Psychological studies appeal to me. I bet I would enjoy this film.

  8. Pingback: Greatest Film I’ve Never Seen Blogathon – Day 1 Recap – MOON IN GEMINI

  9. There is not one film that I don’t like from Bresson. It had a great career. Now days directors have the ups and downs. But Bresson was awesome. I have almost all his collection. I so love this film.

  10. Jane says:

    I haven’t seen or heard of this so thank you, I’m reading Crime and Punishment next year so will watch with it. What a great idea for a blogathon!

  11. I’m another one who hasn’t heard of this film. It’s sounds intriguing and I hope to come across it soon.

  12. Keith says:

    Oh I loved reading this. I absolutely adore Bresson and it warms my heart to read others talking about his work. Pickpocket is fantastic.

  13. Debbie says:

    This is a film that took me a while to fully appreciate, but now I love it.

    It’s interesting that you mentioned Paul Schrader, because he kind of/sort of remade the film (not officially, it just shares a lot with the original). It’s called Light Sleeper. If you haven’t seen it, I recommend it.

    Thanks so much for contributing to the blogathon!

  14. Arti says:

    Bresson is one of my favourite directors of all time. I’ve several of his works from Criterion Collection, ‘Pickpocket’ is one of them. I’ve appreciated your review here and with your commentary on the film ‘Drive’ on another post, and your mention of Paul Schrader here. Because coincidentally, I’ve a post some years back comparing ‘Pickpocket’ and ‘Drive’ using Flannery O’Connor’s idea of ‘intrusions of grace.’ If you’re interested, here’s that post.

    BTW, Schrader’s version of ‘Pickpocket’ can be found in ‘American Gigolo’, almost exact ending.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

The First Gates

Stories, Dreams, Imagination, Soul

SaylingAway

Shorts, Novels, and Other Things

munchingpopcorn

5 second babblings on movies and TV shows...

Flavia Vinci

Here, Now and Somewhere else

Cincinnati Babyhead

Speaks his mind on music & movies!

Through the Shattered Lens

Where mainstream meets grindhouse, exploitation, otaku and gamers

Phantom Paper

Ghosts of thoughts past

Content Catnip

Quirky internet wunderkammer

%d bloggers like this: